Your local guide

Best of Islip

Vote for your favorite local businesses in Islip. Verify your email, opt in to city updates, and choose the places you love.

THE PEOPLE’S LOCAL FAVORITES

Vote for your local favorites

Who makes the best tacos? Where do you take a friend for coffee? Give your favorite local places a little recognition.

Vote now →

One vote per verified email, category and year. You can change your choice. Voting requires an explicit opt-in to this city’s email updates and local business offers. You can unsubscribe at any time.

Find your category

See current community vote totals

A starting point for exploring Islip

Explore a shortlist from our researched local directory. Each group explains how its places were selected. These suggestions are separate from the community votes above and do not represent a citywide award.

Each profile links to its sources. Ratings, where available, can change. Use the heart on a photo to save a place for later.

See your saved places →

Local restaurants to get to know

Independent kitchens, neighborhood cafes and places for your next meal.

An alphabetical selection of researched local places. This is not a rating or popularity ranking.

Sports bar

1683 Bar

Sports bar · 401 Sunrise Hwy

1683 Bar is located at 401 Sunrise Highway in West Islip, New York. The business is situated in the Town of Islip. The bar offers a range of food options, including burgers, salads, and desserts. It also has a selection of drinks, such as cocktails and draft beer. 1683 Bar has a weekly schedule of events, including Martini and Margarita Mondays, Taco and Tequila Tuesdays, Wine Wednesdays, and Ladies Night Thursdays. On Sundays, the bar serves brunch. The business can be contacted at 631-500-0650 or through its website. 1683 Bar is a sports bar and restaurant that aims to provide a comfortable environment for its customers. It has a rustic modern ambiance and offers activities such as darts.

Pizza restaurant

Angela's Pizzeria

Pizza restaurant · 192 Islip Ave

Angela's Pizzeria is located at 192 Islip Ave in Islip, NY. The pizzeria offers a variety of menu items, including pizzas, appetizers, soups, salads, side orders, calzones, heroes, wraps, paninis, sliders, pasta, baked pasta, and entrees. Some of the pizzeria's specialty pizzas include the Grandma Pizza, Brooklyn Pizza, Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza, and the Islip Avenue Pizza. They also offer a range of appetizers, such as fried ravioli, mozzarella sticks, and garlic knots. In addition to their regular menu, Angela's Pizzeria also offers daily specials, including a Monday Special and a Thursday Special. They also have a catering menu, which includes options such as house salad, Caesar salad, and penne a la vodka. They also offer a lunch special, which includes a choice of any slice, side of pasta, or side salad with three garlic knots.

Pizza restaurant

Anthony's Pizza & Pasta

Pizza restaurant · 791 Udall Rd

Anthony's Pizza & Pasta is located at 791 Udall Rd in West Islip, NY. The business offers a variety of menu items, including pizzas, salads, and pasta dishes. Some of the menu items include Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad, Pasta with Marinara Sauce, and Ravioli. They also offer a range of pizzas, such as Classic cheese, Sicilian, and Gourmet Pizzas. The restaurant has a range of options for customers, including delivery and pickup. Customers can order online or by phone at (631) 321-4100. Anthony's Pizza & Pasta can be found on the Slice app and has a presence on social media. Customers can get directions to the restaurant by visiting the Slice website. The restaurant is located in West Islip, NY, and customers can contact them by phone or through the Slice app. The business address is 791 Udall Rd, West Islip, NY 11795.

Texmex restaurant

Avocados Mexican-American Grill

Texmex restaurant · 1360 Lakeland Ave

Avocados Mexican-American Grill is located at 1360 Lakeland Avenue in Bohemia, New York. The restaurant serves American Mexican food, prepared in-house with fresh ingredients. The menu features a range of dishes, including appetizers, salads, tacos, quesadillas, fajitas, burritos, and empanadas. Some options include chicken, pork, beef, and vegetable choices, as well as steak, shrimp, and fish. Avocados Mexican-American Grill also offers catering services, with a customizable menu featuring dishes such as burritos, tacos, quesadillas, and nachos. The restaurant can cater events such as birthday parties, holiday parties, and corporate events. Customers can dine in at the restaurant or place an order by calling 631-750-3820. Orders can also be placed online. The restaurant has a presence on social media platforms, including Facebook, Instagram, and Google. Customers can contact the restaurant by phone or email, and the website provides a link to apply for jobs.

Bagel shop

Bagel Buzz

Bagel shop · 498 Union Blvd

Bagel Buzz is a bagel shop located in West Islip, New York. The shop features a wide array of bagels, homemade flavored cream cheeses, and specialty breakfast sandwiches. In addition to its bagel offerings, Bagel Buzz also has a full lunch and catering menu. This includes specialty sandwiches like the Beechwood Bum and the Maple Madness, which can be paired with homemade soups. Customers can also create their own chopped salads with over 35 vegetables to choose from. Bagel Buzz is situated in the Captree Village Shopping Center on Union Boulevard, in the heart of the West Islip community. The shop can be contacted by phone or fax for more information.

Bar and grill restaurant

Bayside Clam Bar & Grill

Bar and grill restaurant · 300 Bayview Ave

Bayside Clam Bar & Grill is a restaurant located in the Town of Islip, specifically in East Islip. The restaurant is situated in the East Islip Marina, offering waterfront dining with views of the Great South Bay and Fire Island. The menu at Bayside Clam Bar & Grill features a variety of options, including fresh seafood, classic American dishes, and handcrafted cocktails. Some of the menu items include Little Neck Clams on the Half Shell, Blue Point Oysters on the Half Shell, and Bayside's Baked Clams. In addition to its menu, the restaurant also offers live music and a lively atmosphere. The space is designed to provide a satisfying waterfront dining experience, with stunning views of the surrounding area. The restaurant can be contacted at 631-277-9100 or through email at [email protected] or [email protected] The address of the restaurant is 300 Bayview Avenue, East Islip, NY 11730.

Independent shops worth exploring

Browse locally rooted shops and find something beyond the usual chains.

An alphabetical selection of researched local places. This is not a rating or popularity ranking.

Carpet store

Alita Tile

Carpet store · 4465 Sunrise Hwy

Alita Tile is a business located in the Town of Islip, specifically in Bohemia, New York. The business offers an extensive selection of tiles for various projects, including renovations and designing commercial spaces. The business has a showroom featuring over 35 bathroom displays, showcasing diverse styles and layouts. They also offer an extensive inventory of in-stock and special order items, including ceramic, mosaic, marble, and porcelain tiles. At Alita Tile, customers can find expert consultants who provide a unique tile selection experience. The consultants help customers choose the perfect tiles and offer advice on complementary materials. The business also offers complimentary appointments with experienced designers to help customers select the perfect tiles and materials for their projects. The business is located at 4465 Sunrise Highway, Bohemia, NY 11716, and can be contacted by phone at 631-589-8453 or by email at customerservice@alitatile.com. Customers can also fill out an online form to get in touch with the business.

Sporting goods store

Arbore Bros Pools & Spas

Sporting goods store · 160 Higbie Ln

Arbore Bros Pools & Spas is located at 160 Higbie Lane in West Islip, New York. The business is situated in the Town of Islip. The company offers various products, including supplies, chemicals, and parts for pools and spas. They also provide water analysis services. Arbore Bros Pools & Spas is an authorized dealer for several brands, including ProTeam, Polaris, and Hayward. They have a service center for these brands. Customers can visit the store or contact them at (631) 321-1234. The business has a photo gallery and provides gift certificates. Customers can get directions to the store or send a message to the business.

Furniture store

Bayshore Furniture & Mattress

Furniture store · 13 Pine Aire Dr

Bayshore Furniture & Mattress is a furniture store located at 13 Pine Aire Dr. in Bayshore, NY. The store offers a wide range of furniture products, including living room, dining room, bedroom, and office furniture, as well as mattresses and home accents. The store's product catalog includes items such as sofas, sectionals, recliners, accent chairs, beds, dressers, nightstands, dining tables, chairs, and buffets. They also carry a variety of mattresses, including innerspring, memory foam, and hybrid styles. In addition to their physical showroom, Bayshore Furniture & Mattress also offers online shopping, allowing customers to browse and purchase their products from the comfort of their own homes. The store provides delivery and flexible financing options to customers in the Bay Shore, NY area. Bayshore Furniture & Mattress carries furniture in a range of styles, including modern, contemporary, traditional, and farmhouse. Their products are available in various materials, such as leather, fabric, wood, and metal, and are designed to fit different budgets and decorating needs.

Sporting goods store

Black Widow Training Gear

Sporting goods store · 1340 Lincoln Ave

Black Widow Training Gear is located in Holbrook, New York. The business is situated at 1340 Lincoln Ave Unit 3. This company offers various products, including specialty bars, racks, rack attachments, cable attachments, landmines, and accessories. Some of the specific items available are the Safety Squat Bar, Multi Grip Press Bar, and Dip Station. Customers can also request custom orders, which allows them to work with the company to create gear that fits their specific needs and space. The company's products are handmade in New York. The company has a lead time of up to 10-12 weeks due to high demand. They release a limited number of slots to ensure timely delivery, and customers can join a waitlist to secure a spot in the next cycle. Customers can contact the company through phone at +1 631-615 2723 or email at sales@blackwidowtg.com. The company can be found on social media platforms such as Facebook, Instagram, YouTube, and Twitter. They also have a newsletter that customers can sign up for to receive updates and information about new products.

Linen store

Brulhardt Brothers

Linen store · 315 Myrtle Ave

Brulhardt Brothers is a family-owned business located at 315 Myrtle Ave, West Islip, NY 11795. The business has been operating since 1920 and provides various services related to window treatments. The company offers custom-made draperies, window treatments, and upholstery services. They also provide motorized systems and controls for curtains and shades. Additionally, they offer restoration services for delicate furniture and custom foam cushion cutting. Brulhardt Brothers has a team of design experts who can help clients choose the right window treatments for their homes or offices. They offer a range of products, including natural woven shades, custom-made shades and curtains, and architectural shading solutions. The business can be contacted at 212-829-8330 or via email at [email protected] They have a website where clients can learn more about their services and products. Brulhardt Brothers is committed to providing its clients with the products and services they need to improve the design, comfort, and privacy of their homes or businesses.

Specialty foods store

Chef Jojo's Cookshop

Specialty foods store · 1895 Union Blvd

Chef Jojo's Cookshop is located at 1895 Union Boulevard in Bay Shore, New York. The business is situated in the Town of Islip. The shop offers a variety of food items, including chef-made meals and local market products. These items are available for customers to take home and enjoy. The menu at Chef Jojo's Cookshop changes weekly and features dishes such as lentil soup, beef chili, and Greek chicken salad. In addition to its food offerings, Chef Jojo's Cookshop aims to provide a unique shopping experience. The shop is stocked with a curated selection of products, and the staff take care to prepare each item. The shop's address and contact information are available for those who wish to get in touch.

Make a day of it

Museums, galleries and cultural stops from our city directory.

An alphabetical selection of researched local places. This is not a rating or popularity ranking.

Art gallery

Bird Carvings From the Wild

Art gallery · 28 West Ln

Bird Carvings From the Wild is an art gallery located in the Town of Islip, New York, specifically in Bay Shore. The business offers hand-carved and hand-painted birds, including songbirds, shorebirds, birds of prey, hanging ornaments, and wall plaques. The birds are carved from bass wood, hand-feathered to show detail, and painted with acrylic paint. They have metal feet and glass eyes, and are life-sized unless otherwise indicated. The business also offers unique woodpecker doorknockers that can be screwed to a door or door frame. The business is owned and operated by Henry and Sue Boudreau, who have a long-time interest in birds. They guarantee customer satisfaction with their purchases, and offer refunds or replacements if customers are not happy with their purchases. Customers can view the available birds on the business's website or visit their location in Bay Shore. The business also participates in craft fairs and festivals, with a schedule listed on their website. Customers can contact the business by email or phone to place orders or inquire about their products.

Aquarium

Island Fish and Reef

Aquarium · 505 Johnson Ave

Island Fish and Reef is an aquarium shop based in Bohemia, Suffolk County, New York. The business offers custom design and installation of aquariums, as well as maintenance and stocking services. The company's team of knowledgeable aquarists works with clients to create a unique ecosystem that fits their lifestyle and space. They provide a range of services, including design, installation, stocking, and maintenance of aquariums, for both residential and commercial clients. Island Fish and Reef also offers additional services such as RO water delivery, quarantine and concierge services, and rehabilitation of tanks that require maintenance. They also provide moving services for aquariums, ensuring that the system is fully functional at the new location. The business is located at 505 Johnson Ave, Suite 4, Bohemia, NY 11716, and can be contacted at 631-467-3474. They serve clients throughout Long Island, including Suffolk and Nassau counties. Island Fish and Reef's goal is to provide professional-level care for all aquatic shapes and sizes, and they strive to offer quality service for unique aquariums, whether at home or in the office.

History museum

Long Island Maritime Museum

History museum · 88 West Ave

The Long Island Maritime Museum is committed to the research, preservation, and interpretation of the region's rich nautical heritage and the role of Long Island in the national maritime story. The museum offers various exhibits, including shipwrecks, history, and heritage, as well as education programs, such as lectures, story time, and summer camp. The museum is located on 14 acres of waterfront property in West Sayville and provides a unique experience for visitors of all ages. It showcases the links between Long Island's maritime and natural histories, featuring creatures that live in local waters. The Long Island Maritime Museum has a long history, dating back to its founding by a group of concerned citizens. Over the years, it has developed a collection of vessels, historic buildings, machinery, and artifacts, with support from the Suffolk County Department of Parks, Recreation, and Historic Preservation. The museum offers various events and programs, including the Keels & Wheels Seafood Festival, Thursdays On The Bay, and Halloween Boat Burning. It also provides facility rental and photo shoot opportunities. Visitors can explore the museum's digital archives, which feature videos and documentaries about Long Island's maritime history. The Long Island Maritime Museum is a member of various organizations, including the American Alliance of Museums and the Council of American Maritime Museums. It participates in programs such as Blue Star Museums, which offers free admission to active-duty military personnel and their families, and Museums for All, which provides reduced admission to low-income families.

Museum

LT Michael P. Murphy Navy SEAL Museum

Museum · 50 West Ave

The LT Michael P. Murphy Navy SEAL Museum is located at 50 West Avenue in West Sayville, New York. It has seven exhibition halls, including a movie theater and a simulation ride. The museum tells the story of the Special Operators of Naval Special Warfare Command. The museum is dedicated to honoring the sacrifices and legacies of the Special Operators. It also serves as a learning center for the U.S. Naval Sea Cadets. The museum's mission is to educate visitors about the history and values of the SEAL community. The museum has a classroom facility and offers multiple opportunities for visitors to learn about the SEAL community through films, videos, and exhibits. The museum is also a place for remembering those who have been lost. The LT Michael P. Murphy Navy SEAL Museum is a non-profit charitable foundation. It is located in close proximity to the Long Island Maritime Museum. The museum has a number of events and activities, including the Murph Challenge and the Annual Golf Classic. It is also closed on certain holidays, including New Year's Day, Easter Sunday, and Thanksgiving. The museum can be contacted at +1 631-589-7325.

Historic site

Sagtikos Manor

Historic site · 677 W Montauk Hwy

Sagtikos Manor is a historic site in the Town of Islip. It has been around for over 300 years and has a lot of history. The manor was built and has been used for many things over the years. The Sagtikos Manor Historical Society was founded by Islip Town Historian George L. Weeks, Jr. and a small group. The society is in charge of preserving the manor and its grounds. They also give tours of the manor. People can take a tour of the manor and see its many rooms. The manor has a lot of historic items and artifacts on display. Visitors can also walk around the grounds, which are open to the public daily. The manor is located at 677 W Montauk Highway in West Bay Shore. It is open for tours on Fridays, Saturdays, and Sundays. People can contact the society for more information or to schedule a private tour. The society has a board of directors and many volunteers who help with events and restoration projects. They also have a museum and library with many historic items and documents. The society's goal is to preserve the manor and its history for future generations.

History museum

The Gallery Of Shorthand

History museum · 100 Federal Plz

The Gallery of Shorthand is located in the Alfonse M. D’Amato Federal Courthouse in Central Islip, New York. The gallery celebrates shorthand reporters and their role in preserving the rhetoric of society. The gallery features a collection of steno machines, including some of the earliest and most rare models. The steno machine is a crucial tool for steno writers, allowing them to write down everything they hear with a high degree of accuracy. The gallery's collection includes machines from various countries, including the United States, France, and Japan. The Gallery of Shorthand is housed in the entry rotunda of the federal courthouse and is a gift to the community from the Board of Judges. The US General Services Administration provided exhibit space, and the US District Court for the Eastern District of New York funded the build-out of the display area. The gallery offers group events and lectures, both on-site and off-site. Visitors to the gallery can park for free at the courthouse, and the Long Island MacArthur Airport is just a short drive away. There are also several hotels in the area that offer comfortable accommodations. The gallery is a 501(c)(3) public charity, and donations are welcome. The gallery also has a social media presence and offers email updates and special announcements. The gallery's mission is to celebrate the history and importance of shorthand reporting. It honors the reporters who have preserved the discussions and debates of societies and governments throughout history. The gallery is a unique and fascinating resource for anyone interested in the history of shorthand and its role in shaping our understanding of the world.

Want a different neighborhood or cuisine? Search all 144 places in our directory →. These selections are not paid placements.